Four in Five Workers Say Flexible Working Matters. The Law Is About to Agree.
Flexible working has mostly lived as a culture conversation. From autumn 2027, it becomes a legal one. Acas research published in 2026 found that 78% of UK employees say flexible working matters to them. Under the Employment Rights Act 2025, employers will only be able to refuse a flexible working request where the refusal is reasonable. The two shifts, rising employee expectation and a tightened legal standard, are arriving almost together.
Photo by Vitaly Gariev on Unsplash
What the law actually requires
Eight statutory grounds for refusing a flexible working request already exist:
- extra cost
- inability to reorganise work among existing staff
- inability to recruit
- detriment to quality
- detriment to performance
- insufficient work during the proposed hours
- a planned structural change
- failure to meet customer demand
Right now, citing one of these grounds is enough on its own. From autumn 2027, it will not be. An employer will also have to show that refusing this particular request, on that ground, was reasonable.
Where a request cannot be agreed straight away, employers will need to hold a meeting within the existing two-month decision window. The meeting must give the employee fair notice of its purpose. It must set out the specific challenge the employer has identified. It must consider genuine alternatives before any is rejected. The discussion and the outcome then need to be recorded and confirmed to the employee in writing.
Acas is due to publish guidance on the reasonableness test by the end of 2026. A revised Acas Code of Practice is expected before Parliament in early summer 2027. The full regime takes effect that autumn. Employment tribunals, which already take over two years to hear a claim, will decide what counts as reasonable, one case at a time. Early decisions are likely to set the tone for the cases that follow.
Barclays already found out what happens without it
In September 2026, Barclays told UK staff to attend the office three days a week from 5 October, with managing directors expected four days a week. Unite, which represents around 80% of Barclays' 45,000 UK staff, organised an open letter against the change. Thousands of employees backed it.
Barclays postponed the new requirement to early 2027 and said it was reviewing its flexible working policy. Unite is still negotiating compensation for higher commuting costs and exemptions for staff with long commutes.
Barclays is not alone. TSB staff have threatened legal action over Santander's plans for a similar three-day office requirement from 2027. The dispute at Barclays looks like a preview of a wider pattern across financial services.
Barclays made the call unilaterally, then reversed it under pressure. That is exactly the pattern the Employment Rights Act 2025 is designed to close. A reasonableness test requires employers to document the reasoning behind a refusal, in addition to the decision itself.
Photo by Helena Lopes on Unsplash
What to do before autumn 2027
Three changes are worth making now, not after the law lands.
Check what your flexible working refusals actually record. A line manager's verbal no, with a brief note citing a statutory ground, will not meet the new standard. The reasoning, the alternatives considered, and the meeting itself all need a paper trail.
Train the managers who handle these requests. The reasonableness test puts judgment in the hands of whoever runs that meeting. Untrained judgment is where inconsistent decisions, and tribunal claims, tend to start.
Treat flexible working as a retention question as well as a compliance one. The Acas research behind the 78% figure measured how much flexibility affects where people choose to work and whether they stay. Lambeth Council is separately assessing a four-day week trial for its own staff, extending the debate into the public sector too. A workforce that already knows the answer to the flexibility question will not wait for the law to catch up.
Photo by Josh Marty on Unsplash
HBP's leadership and management training builds exactly this kind of judgment: giving managers the skill to run a fair, well-documented conversation under a new legal standard. Organisations that get ahead of October 2027 will spend less time explaining a decision to a tribunal and more time running a workforce that trusts the process.
