Skip to content


☎  +44 (0) 333 33 55 318   


@   hello@humanbypractice.co.uk

Equality Duty, Legal & Compliance Professionalism & Ethics Case Studies & Client Stories

Whistleblowing Claims Have Doubled. None Won at Tribunal Last Quarter.

Jess Sandham
Jess Sandham

UK whistleblowing complaints rose by 104% in the past year. Ministry of Justice tribunal data puts the new total at 1,546 detriment claims. In the second quarter of 2025-26, 519 whistleblowing cases reached a hearing. None succeeded.

That combination matters. More people are raising concerns through formal channels. Very few are succeeding once a case reaches a tribunal hearing. The government has noticed too. On 12 October 2026 it opened a consultation that could make whistleblowing procedures a legal requirement outside financial services for the first time.

Four colleagues in a board meeting listening to a colleague speak

Photo by Mapbox on Unsplash

A sharp rise, a low success rate

The 104% rise sits inside a longer pattern. Whistleblowing claims have moved from a rare feature of employment litigation to a routine one. High-profile cases, including the Post Office scandal and Harrods, have pushed the subject into public view. Compensation for detriment or dismissal tied to a protected disclosure is uncapped. That raises the financial exposure for any employer who gets the response wrong.

A zero-success quarter does not mean every claim lacked merit. Tribunals set a demanding test. The worker has to show a qualifying disclosure, made in the public interest, that caused the treatment they are complaining about. Employers who keep a protected disclosure clearly separate from an ordinary grievance, with a documented trail showing that separation, fare far better under scrutiny. Most employers have no such documentation.

A group of five colleagues in discussion around a table

Photo by Christina @ wocintechchat.com on Unsplash

What the government is proposing

The consultation runs until 8 January 2027. It considers a legal duty for private employers with 50 or more staff, and for every public sector employer, to hold a whistleblowing policy, run secure reporting channels, and follow up on each disclosure. One option borrows from Irish law: written acknowledgement within seven days, a named person responsible for each case, and feedback to the whistleblower within three months. A second option borrows from the FCA's SYSC 18 regime, already used by regulated firms, who may be exempt from any new duty on the basis they already meet an equivalent standard.

A separate strand asks whether the UK should introduce US-style financial rewards for reporting economic crime to the Serious Fraud Office. Comparable schemes elsewhere pay 10% to 30% of the resulting fine. HMRC's own reward scheme already pays up to 30%. The consultation asks whether a UK scheme should cap rewards at all. It also proposes new criminal offences: one for knowingly making a false report, another for harassing a whistleblower who uses the scheme.

Two colleagues in conversation at a desk

Photo by Centre for Ageing Better on Unsplash

What this means for your organisation now

Waiting for the consultation to close is not a plan. Outside financial services, no employer is currently required to have a whistleblowing policy at all. The claims data shows people are raising concerns regardless of whether a clear process exists for them. A policy that lives only in a handbook creates the same risk as no policy at all. When a tribunal examines how a disclosure was handled, it looks at what actually happened. It does not look at what the handbook says should happen.

HBP's psychological safety and speak-up training draws on the same evidence this consultation cites. Managers need a clear, practised routine for the moment someone raises a concern. That means knowing who acknowledges it, who owns the case, and how the person stays updated. It also means keeping a protected disclosure separate from any performance conversation running at the same time. That last point is where most real risk sits. A manager who blends the two, even without meaning to, hands a tribunal exactly the pattern it looks for.

Employers with 50 or more staff should treat a statutory duty as close to certain, not merely possible. Building the reporting infrastructure now, while the design choices are still yours, beats having a model imposed by regulation later.

Share this post